a place for interesting concepts
10 Magnificent Board Games Like Clue in 2024
March 30th, 2024 - By Steve Chang
If you found Clue intriguing, numerous similar games are ready to captivate you even more.

If you've got a knack for suspenseful narratives and logical deductions, you're bound to love good old Clue. Essentially, Clue is an intriguing board game of manipulation, mystery, and murder where players take on the roles of suspects in a murder case, trying to figure out who the killer is, with which weapon, and in what room. Sure, the gameplay might feel like an Agatha Christie novel come to life, but it's much more than that. It encourages strategic thinking, lateral thinking, and a dash of poker face bluffing, separating it from many typical family board games. Plus, there's a reason it has remained a classic and one of the best-selling board games worldwide; the countless permutations keep each match interesting and create thrilling ‘whodunnit’ scenarios, making every gathering a hit.

Now, if Clue caught your interest, I bet you're keen on similar detective board games that present their own unique twists to the whodunnit genre. There's a treasure trove of strategic and mystery board games out there designed to pump up the adrenaline, ranging from supernatural whodunits to complex crime scene investigations. Many of these play with elements that Clue fans will find familiar yet innovative, challenging your problem-solving skills and intuition in brand new ways. If you're drawn to the suspense and deductive reasoning that Clue offers, there are, in fact, quite a few board games that...

10. Mysterium

If you're a fan of the mystery-solving element in Clue, then Mysterium will definitely be up your alley. They are similar in both being cooperative board games that revolve around solving mysteries. In Mysterium, players work together to decipher clues and uncover a murder mystery, much like the premise of Clue. However, while Clue is centered around deduction and logic, Mysterium delves into interpretation and intuition. You'll definitely enjoy the heightened suspense that comes with the eerie mood of Mysterium, offering a thrilling alternative to the classic Clue game.

Another parallel between Clue and Mysterium is the richness of the game's narrative and substance. Both are not merely games but encapsulate a compelling story that players get to unravel step by step. In Mysterium, instead of simply being a detective, you also interact with the ghost of the victim, who communicates through visions represented by beautifully illustrated cards. This adds a wonderful layer of artistry and imagination that complements the analytical aspects that are reminiscent of Clue. If you fancy the strategic questioning and smart guesses that Clue provides, Mysterium takes it up a notch with psychic interpretations and beautifully crafted gameplay.

Mysterium is typically priced around $50 USD.

9. Deception: Murder in Hong Kong

In the vein of classic murder mystery games like Clue, Deception: Murder in Hong Kong offers a thrilling game-night experience that’s sure to keep everyone on the edge of their seats. The main commonality between Clue and Deception: Murder in Hong Kong is the fundamental objective of uncovering the identity of a murderer. However, Deception raises the stakes by putting you in the shoes of a forensics expert, killer or detective, each with a distinct role to make the game divergent and engaging. Just as in Clue where you are trying to find out who the murderer is, what weapon they used, and where the murder took place, in Deception, you too are trying to identify the killer amidst you along with the murder weapon and evidence left behind, but with more layers of strategy and social deduction. You must be persuasive, perceptive, and shrewd to win, making the game utterly gripping each time you play.

Deception: Murder in Hong Kong is unique in that it incorporates elements of social interaction and role-play that make it more in-depth than Clue. While both games involve discovering a killer and require strategic thinking, Deception takes it a step further by encouraging players to read into their peers behaviours and deduce who among them is the murderer. There's a strong emphasis on discussion and argument, much like a real detective would discuss with their team to solve a case. Just like in Clue, clues are presented to help solve the crime. However, in Deception, these hints are less straightforward, involving interpretation and argumentation. Hence, if you enjoyed the strategic and problem-solving elements in Clue, you're likely to find Deception: Murder in Hong Kong to be an equally immersive and challenging board game to add to your collection.

Deception: Murder in Hong Kong is typically priced around $40 USD.

8. Kill Dr. Lucky

Kill Dr. Lucky is a thrilling board game that also requires strategic deduction skills, very similar to the classic game you've enjoyed, Clue. Just like in Clue, where you are a detective trying to discover the murderer, the murder weapon, and the location of the crime, in Kill Dr. Lucky you are also on a quest. However, the twist here is that each player is the potential murderer and the aim is to kill Dr. Lucky without any witnesses present. This clever inversion of the Clue concept keeps the essence of deduction, strategic planning, and player interaction intact while providing an entirely fresh and exciting gaming experience.

The similarities extend to the board set-up too; like the rooms in the Clue mansion, in Kill Dr. Lucky, players navigate through a complex mansion layout filled with numerous rooms and secret passages. The suspense builds with each turn as you venture closer to the doomed victim. Movements must be carefully planned, keeping in mind the positions of the other players. The uncertainty of player strategies and the randomness of the cards provide unforeseen challenges and twists, making for a tense, unpredictable, and enjoyable gaming experience that shares the charm of mystery and intrigue with Clue.

Kill Dr. Lucky is typically priced around $30 USD.

7. 221B Baker Street

If you're a fan of whodunit games like Clue, you'll find 221B Baker Street a fantastic choice! Unique in its approach to detective work and crime-solving, this board game pulls heavily from the world and characters of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes series for a rich and challenging gameplay experience. Similar to Clue, the game revolves around solving mysteries through the gathering of clues with each varying in complexity. The game comes with a book of cases for players to solve, providing almost endless replayability. Another feature that sets this game apart and would delight Clue players is the sense of competition among detectives on the board; you're in a race against other players to be the first to unveil the culprit, taking the cutthroat strategy aspect of Clue to an exciting new level.

The game board represents Sherlock Holmes's city, London in the late 19th century, bringing another layer of immersion. The board offers various locations for characters to visit in search of clues and leads, comparable to the different rooms in Clue where players search for hints to the murder. The clues are given in riddles and puzzles which makes it more engaging and requires keen observation and critical thinking, just like in-game decisions in Clue. With memorable characters, deduction, strategic movement, and the thrill of discovering secrets, 221B Baker Street delivers a similar yet enhanced gaming experience for fans of Clue.

221B Baker Street is typically priced around $25 USD.

6. Mystery of the Abbey

Just like Clue, Mystery of the Abbey is a compelling deduction game set in the cool, quiet corridors of a medieval monastery. The goal is to solve the mysterious disappearance of a monk, making this board game very similar to the murder mystery theme of Clue. The catch is that rather than identifying the killer, weapon, and location, players are tasked with piecing together clues that will reveal the identity of the missing brother. The game's mechanics are fascinatingly intricate, involving the careful questioning of fellow players to gather information and subsequently rule out potential culprits.

One of the major similarities between Mystery of the Abbey and Clue is the use of deduction and hypothesis. Players will find themselves strategizing and making conjectures based on gathered information in their quest to unravel the mystery. Much like Clue, the game's charm lies in its multifaceted nature, requiring keen observation, attention to detail, and strategic decision-making. From suspect interrogation to manuscript guides that contain secrets, Mystery of the Abbey incorporates a wealth of intriguing elements that add depth and excitement to the game, enhancing the game's similarity to the thrilling narrative of Clue.

Mystery of the Abbey is typically priced around $55 USD.

5. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective

In many ways, Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective shares similarities with the classic board game Clue, but with a more immersive and comprehensive approach. Like Clue, it is a mystery-based game where you play as an investigator and use clues to solve crimes. If you enjoyed the mental gymnastics and deduction required in Clue, you'd absolutely love the challenge posed by Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective. It extends beyond simply figuring out the weapon, place, and perpetrator; players are tasked to dissect complex narratives, interview suspects, and string together evidence to solve intricate cases, essentially making you the star of your detective novel. The game's beautifully rendered maps of Victorian-era London and high-quality materials make the whole experience even more engaging.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective shares Clue’s competitive nature, but also adds cooperative elements. Players work together to solve the mystery, yet compete to be the best individual detective. If you reveled in the competitive aspect of Clue, then the contrasting challenges of teamwork and individualism in Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective would keep you on your toes. Plus, the game's non-linear structure means that every move you make shapes the outcome, keeping every playthrough fresh and exciting – a significant leap from Clue’s repeated formula.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective is typically priced around $50 USD.

4. Betrayal at House on the Hill

The first parallel between Betrayal at House on the Hill and Clue is their central focus on mystery. Just like in Clue, where the players are detectives trying to figure out the identity of the murderer, the location of the murder, and the weapon used, Betrayal at House on the Hill asks its players to uncover the secrets hidden within a haunted manor. Throughout the game, you'll explore the house, unveiling new rooms and exciting narrative snippets that give away tiny pieces of the bigger picture just like you'd uncover clues in Clue.

Another striking similarity is the potential for a traitor among the players. In Clue, the killer is one of the players; it's fun because you have to carefully observe your co-players while trying to put the pieces of the puzzle together. In Betrayal at House on the Hill, once the haunt is revealed, one player might turn out to be a traitor working against the team. Consequently, this heightens the suspense of the game, mirroring Clue's tense atmosphere where everyone's a suspect. Both games create an interactive, cooperative yet competitive gameplay experience guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat.

Betrayal at House on the Hill is typically priced around $50 USD.

3. Mr. Jack

If you've always been a fan of Clue, Mr. Jack is a board game that will love. Like Clue, Mr. Jack is a mystery-themed game that plays out on a beautifully designed board, featuring a charmingly depicted Parliament of London. Central to the game is a thrilling hunt for a concealed character - similar to seeking out the murderer in Clue. Both games require sharp deduction skills, careful strategy, and a keen eye for detail, where every choice can lead closer to the solution or further off the track.

The game mechanic in Mr. Jack is also somewhat reminiscent of Clue. In each round, players alternately play characters who either help Jack to escape or strive to get detectives closer to capturing him. This gives the game an element of suspense and constant guessing that is so characteristic of Clue. As each round passes, you gather more information, formulate hypotheses and make educated guesses, similar to our beloved Clue. With its intricate gameplay, rich narrative plot, and captivating artwork, Mr. Jack effortlessly captures the essence of a true detective board game just like Clue.

Mr. Jack is typically priced around $30 USD.

2. Scotland Yard

One of the most likable aspects of Clue is its strong element of mystery and deduction, a feature which Scotland Yard shares in abundance. Just like Clue, Scotland Yard is a detective-centric board game that showcases a similar cat-and-mouse chase where strategic thinking and problem-solving skills are put to test. You'll absolutely enjoy the plot twists and investigation process as you traverse across the legendary map of London, hunting down the elusive Mr. X. It promotes a just as engaging, if not more, team synergy where players collaborate in teams to outsmart the opponent, enhancing the fun and interactive social experience. Also, the game is brilliant in maintaining suspense since Mr. X's location is always a secret, spicing up the similarity to Clue's whodunit mystery.

I believe you're going to appreciate the complexity of Scotland Yard because, just like in Clue, careful observation and strategizing are crucial in this board game. Scotland Yard is also familiar with Clue's multiple possibilities scenario; as a detective, various routes can be taken to catch Mr. X, like taxis, buses, or the underground, adding a factor of unpredictability and infinite replay value. And just like Clue, Scotland Yard features a wonderful blend of competition and cooperation that allows for engaging social interaction and cerebral gameplay. As you try to deduce Mr. X's location based on his mode of transportation, you'll find that Scotland Yard takes the deducing mechanic of Clue and levels it up into a thrilling hide-and-seek board game adventure, conveniently offering a fresh perspective yet maintaining the comfort of the familiar.

Scotland Yard is typically priced around $37.99 USD. It offers an equally exciting and thought-provoking experience as Clue, making it a worthy addition to your board game collection if you loved the thrill of uncovering secrets in Clue.

1. The Resistance

The Resistance, much like Clue, is based on strategizing, bluffing, and deduction. The heart of both games revolves around unravelling a hidden truth while being misled by other players. While Clue has you hunting for a killer, weapon, and location, The Resistance places you in the midst of a futuristic dystopia where you and your team are trying to launch a rebellion against an oppressive government. Just like Clue, you'll find yourself constantly questioning the alliances and loyalty of your fellow players, making it an engaging social deduction game.

Where The Resistance differs, and yet resembles Clue, is in its gameplay elements. Both games are full of suspense as players strategize to outsmart their opponents. Much like Clue, where you gather evidence and make accusations, The Resistance has you going on missions and voting for team members; all while trying to figure out who the hidden spies are in your team. The immersive nature of this game's deception and deduction elements will excite Clue enthusiasts.

The Resistance is typically priced around $20 USD.

You've reached the end! Check out the home page for more informative articles on your favorite games.